Anne's eyes meander through lines of text. She dips her spoon into the bowl of chicken and noodles, but it's some time before she picks it up again. “Frank,” she yells. “Frank, come here.”
He walks into the kitchen wearing a flannel shirt and a preoccupied expression; focused on his fingernails, he says, "What is it?"
"We know him, don't we?" Anne points at the newspaper on the table. "Don't we know him?" She looks up and sees Frank not paying attention. "Anthony Petrano," she says. "How do we know him?"
Frank picks under the nail of a pinky with his thumb and shrugs without looking up. “Doesn't ring a bell,” he says.
“Oh, come on,” says Anne. “Anthony Petrano. I know we know him. Does he go to St. Luke's?”
“Maybe,” says Frank. “Petrano. Sounds Italian – probably Catholic.” He moves to the refrigerator and opens it, leans into its cold glow and hum. The sound of Anne whispering the name to herself floats through the room. Her voice mingles with the sound of raking leaves and falls into a syncopated rhythm with the scrapes.
"Petrano...Petrano..." Anne says. "Do you think he's maybe in mom's tennis league?"
Hidden by the refrigerator door, Frank shrugs. He picks through some leftovers, but doesn't take anything out.
"Come look at this picture, and tell me if we know him. I swear we know him, Frank."
"Annie, I told you, I don't."
"Just come here for a second. Look at this."
Frank widens his eyes and flares his nostrils with an exasperated inhalation, but he closes the door and walks to the kitchen table. He stands behind her chair and looks over her shoulder as if he were proctoring a geometry test. His eyes scan the article from the bottom up: the blurred, gray text, a grainy photograph, the headline.
“His wife's name is Alice. Do you recognize that? Alice Petrano?”
“He's dead?”
Anne nods.
“He's dead?”
“Yeah,” Anne says. “Car accident, last night. Some kids. I wonder if...was he on the City Council?”
“Let me see that.” Frank leans over his wife – he doesn't touch her, doesn't brush her hair with his billowed shirt – and picks up the paper; the newsprint crackles in his hands. The article isn't long. He scans it, the picture, the article again.
Anthony Petrano was pronounced dead at the scene, killed by three Union College students in a Ford Escort. An accident. “A simple accident,” the paper says, but Anthony Petrano is dead. Frank can picture them, all of them – the three kids, and the wife who heard the crash and ran outside – all huddled around the body, all looking down with hands held over their mouths – it was dark enough that they couldn't really see, Frank pictures, so they couldn't just look, but had to peer at the body – everyone waiting for something, for recognition, for an arm to move or a voice to sound out in the still air, and nothing happening but people standing there, silent and held back by their own hands.
Or it wasn't like that. The wife was screaming, maybe. Slapping and hysterical, her arms swinging and chopping and smacking at the others. Belting those two teenage boys with words like, “Why,” and, “How,” and, “No,” and, “No.” The young men with arms held up and crossed for protection, shielding themselves with “Please,” and “Wait.” “You don't understand.”
And the girl – the girl who the woman had forgotten about – maybe, the girl, she stepped quietly, and maybe, the girl, she reached quietly, and maybe she touched quietly, touched, with just the tips of her fingers, maybe, she touched the back of the woman's shoulder, to calm her, the woman, she touched her, the girl. But the woman, in high dudgeon now, in full fury, she reacted in full fury and swung the back of her hand around the back of her body so that it landed with, not a smack, but with a thud on the girl's already reddened cheek. And although the diamond set in the woman's engagement ring was small and dulled like a milky eye from its years, it cut just the same, just as sharp, just as clean, just like the sharpest thing in the world. One long gash of blood opened on the girl's face, and the scar would someday become the kind of a scar that an artist would draw on a comic book anti-hero to show that, for all of the lives she'd saved, for all the good she'd done, there was a dark side lurking beneath her surface, the girl's, a dark side just itching and waiting to crawl out from that slashed up piece of skin.
“You don't think he was one of the old men who works at the Price Chopper, do you?”
“What?”
“What? Maybe he was. You don't know.”
“Anne, he's just a guy who got hit by a car.”
“Yeah, but I know him. I swear.” Anne grabs the paper back and flattens it on the table.
“Just give it a rest.”
She doesn't seem to hear him. Frank walks to the counter, takes a bagel from a plastic bag, slices it, and puts it in the toaster. He watches her read. The article ended with a quote from the wife, Alice. What happened when she heard the crash: “My heart just sank. It just sank right through the floor,” and Frank can picture that, too. He pictures it happening now, to his wife, at the table. A red, squishy plummet that tumbles from her chest, disappears down through formica, down through the floorboards and into the empty bedroom below. It falls like a ghost through the air and seeps into the carpet, into the damp basement cement, and deep deep into the center of the world where Frank can't see it any more. Where it is gone. The bagel pops up and Frank pulls it from the toaster slot. He eats it without condiment.
After a while Alice says, “Those poor kids.”
“What?”
“The kids in the car. It's sad. I mean, what if they go to jail? That one driving? That's vehicular manslaughter, isn't it?”
“Anne.”
“What? You watch the same episodes of Law & Order I do. That's a crime. And this kid is what, eighteen, nineteen years old? It says it was an accident, and poof, that's it. One accident and that's it for him.”
“What about the guy who died?”
“Well, sure, but he's dead. What does he care?”
“You just spent the last twenty minuted trying to figure out if you know this guy. Now you don't want anything to happen to the kid who killed him?”
“That's not what I said. I just said it was an an accident.”
“Well, sure,” Frank says. “But he's dead.” Frank bites into the dry second half of his bagel and looks at his wife until she curls her lips to one side and turns back to the paper again.
“What if it was me,” Anne says, eyes down, half quiet.
“Oh, come on. Don't do this.”
“What? What if it was me? What if I was driving along one day, and I...I don't know, I look down at the radio to change the station. And when I look down, someone starts to cross the street in front of me. Only I don't look up again until it's too late. So even though I slam on the brakes, it's too late, or I hit a patch of wet leaves, or something – black ice – and I crash into him and he's dead. It's an accident but...but there. He's dead. Would I deserve to go to jail?”
“Anne.”
“What? Would I?”
“Anne, come on. That's not even what I was talking about.”
“Well what were you talking about, then?”
A beat, and then Frank flutters his lashes and rolls his eyes; he shakes his head and mutters. “Jesus, I don't know,” he says, just loud enough so Anne can hear. “Just wanted a bagel.”
“What?”
“I said, I don't know, Anne! I don't know! Christ – your questions, this guy. I don't know, okay? I don't know who he is, I don't know how you know him, I don't know what'll happen to this idiot kid or his friends. I don't – just–” His speech runs out of steam, stalls. He looks at his wife and her face is contorted with shock; her eyes wide and framed by her glasses, she looks like a child. She looks like an eleven year-old kid. “You know what – forget it. I'm in the garage. If you want me, I'm in the garage.”
*